Attached English homes divided by a party wall

Party Wall Dispute Process in England: Step by Step

November 05, 2026

A party wall dispute in England begins when a neighbour dissents from your notice, or does not reply in writing within 14 days. It is then settled by surveyors, not by the neighbours arguing it out. Either one agreed surveyor or two appointed surveyors (with a third in reserve) decide the work, how and when it is done, and who pays, in a written document called an award. This guide walks through each stage in order, so you know what to expect and what you can do at each point.

Altura Surveyors
Get Clear Guidance on Party Wall Matters
Altura provides party wall surveying services, helping you understand the surveyor’s role when a dispute arises under the Act.
Explore party wall surveying

TL;DR

  • A dispute is deemed to exist if a neighbour does not consent in writing within 14 days of a party structure notice or counter-notice.
  • Surveyors resolve it under section 10 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996: one agreed surveyor, or one each with a third surveyor selected by the two.
  • The award sets out the work, its timing and manner, and who pays which costs. An appeal to the county court must be made within 14 days of the award being served.
  • Security for expenses and a pre-work condition record protect both sides if something goes wrong.
  • The Act has limits: surveyors cannot decide where a boundary lies, and some disagreements need separate legal advice.

Table of Contents

When a party wall matter becomes a dispute

Most party wall matters never become disputes. You serve a notice, your neighbour consents in writing, and the work goes ahead. The statutory dispute process only begins when that consent does not arrive.

Under section 5 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, a dispute is deemed to arise when an owner who has been served with a party structure notice or counter-notice does not serve written consent within 14 days. That owner is treated as having dissented. Silence therefore counts as a dispute, even if your neighbour has no objection and simply has not got round to answering.

There is one difference for a new wall built astride the boundary. GOV.UK’s explanatory booklet says that where a neighbour does not respond to that kind of notice, the building owner must build wholly on their own land. For existing party structures and excavations, no written response within 14 days creates a deemed dispute.

A dispute can also appear later. The same booklet explains that if a disagreement arises after consent was given, including over damage caused by the works, the statutory dispute procedure applies.

If you are still at the notice stage, our guides to party structure notices and line of junction notices explain what to serve and the notice periods involved.

When a party wall matter becomes a dispute

The dispute process, step by step

The route below follows the Act and GOV.UK’s guidance. Each step has a fixed trigger, so it helps to keep dated copies of everything you send.

  1. Notice served. The building owner serves the correct notice in writing on each affected adjoining owner.
  2. 14 days pass without written consent. A dispute is deemed to have arisen, or the neighbour dissents in writing.
  3. Surveyors are chosen. The owners agree on one surveyor, or each appoints their own.
  4. A written request to appoint, if needed. If one owner does not appoint, the other can ask them in writing to do so.
  5. Default appointment. If the owner still has not appointed after 10 days from that written request, the other owner may appoint a surveyor on their behalf.
  6. Award prepared and served. The surveyor or surveyors settle the disputed matters in writing.
  7. Work starts, subject to the award. The surveyors can be called back if a new disagreement arises.
  8. Appeal, if either owner objects. This goes to the county court, within 14 days of service.

The 10-day default appointment comes from section 10(4) of the Act. It is why ignoring a request does not stop the process. It only means someone else chooses the surveyor for you.

Choosing the surveyors

The Act’s section 10 gives the owners two options.

One agreed surveyor

Both owners jointly appoint a single surveyor in writing. This can be quicker and cheaper because only one person is involved. The agreed surveyor must act impartially and cannot take instructions from either owner alone. It suits straightforward work where both neighbours are on reasonable terms.

Two surveyors and a third

Each owner appoints their own surveyor, and those two select a third. The third surveyor does not usually do anything unless the first two cannot agree. Either owner or either appointed surveyor can then refer the disputed matters to the third surveyor to determine.

This route suits larger or more sensitive projects, or where trust between neighbours is low. Each owner has someone who understands their position, though the surveyors are still bound to be impartial.

How appointments should be made

The RICS professional standard, Party wall legislation and procedure, says appointments must be in writing, made by the relevant owner or by an agent specifically authorised in writing, and should be made directly to the individual surveyor. A casual conversation or a text message is not a valid appointment.

Can the building owner’s surveyor act for the neighbour?

No. Under the Act, a surveyor appointed by one owner does not become the other owner’s surveyor. If your neighbour does not appoint, the building owner may appoint a second surveyor on their behalf, as the 10-day rule above allows. That second surveyor must still be a different person, and GOV.UK explains that appointed surveyors must consider both owners’ interests and rights, acting impartially and resolving matters fairly and practically.

What the surveyors do

A party wall surveyor is not an advocate for one neighbour against the other. Their job is to deal with the matters the Act covers: the right to carry out the work, how and when it is done, access, protective measures and costs.

In practice that usually means:

  • reading the notice and the proposed drawings or method statement;
  • inspecting the adjoining property, and often the building owner’s property too, before work starts;
  • recording the condition of the adjoining property in a schedule;
  • agreeing protective work, working hours or access arrangements where the project calls for them;
  • writing the award.

A condition record is a visual, non-invasive record of what can be seen at the time of inspection. It is not a structural investigation. If a surveyor sees signs that need a closer look, such as significant cracking, the right next step is a specific defect survey or an engineer’s opinion, not a conclusion reached from a walk-through.

What a party wall award decides

The award is the document that settles the dispute. Under section 10 of the Act, it may determine the right to execute the work, the time and manner of doing it, and other matters arising out of or incidental to the dispute, including the costs of the award.

GOV.UK’s explanatory booklet says an award normally records:

  • the work to be done;
  • when and how it will be carried out;
  • any additional protective work;
  • a condition record of the adjoining property before work begins;
  • the surveyors’ access to inspect progress.

On money, GOV.UK’s guidance on what to do if you cannot agree states that the award sets out who pays which share, including the surveyors’ fees. We cover the contents in more detail in our guide to what a party wall award covers.

Once served, the award binds both owners. Read it carefully before work starts, and ask your surveyor to explain any clause you do not follow.

Security for expenses

Security for expenses is a sum of money, or another form of security, set aside so that funds are available if something goes wrong. It is not routine on every project.

According to the RICS standard, security may be justified where there is a particular risk of non-completion, default or foreseeable damage. An adjoining owner’s request for security must be made before the work starts. The amount and form are agreed or determined by the surveyors and recorded in the award.

The same standard describes two ways the money can be held:

  • an escrow bank account, released on the signatures of two of the three surveyors;
  • the client account of an RICS-regulated firm. RICS Regulation treats security held by such a firm under section 12(1) as client money.

If you are the building owner, expect the question on larger or riskier projects, such as deep excavations or work that opens up a shared structure for a long period. If you are the adjoining owner, raise it with your surveyor early, because a request made after work has started comes too late.

Disputes about damage

Damage is the most common cause of trouble after work begins, and it is where a good paper trail matters most.

The condition record described above is the starting point. GOV.UK’s booklet explains that an award can include a condition record so that damage to adjoining land or buildings can be attributed properly and made good. Without one, it is hard to show whether a crack was there before the work.

If damage occurs, a compensation or damage disagreement about work covered by the Act is handled through the same surveyor procedure. The surveyors can also specify protective work in the award to reduce the risk in the first place.

If you notice damage:

  1. Photograph it with the date visible and tell the building owner in writing.
  2. Contact your appointed surveyor, or the agreed surveyor, and ask them to inspect.
  3. Do not start repairs before the surveyor has seen it, unless there is an immediate safety risk.
  4. If the cause is unclear or looks structural, ask for a specific defect inspection rather than guessing.

Where the damage is serious or the cause is uncertain, a specific defect survey can look at a particular problem in more detail. Like all our inspections, it is a visual, non-invasive assessment.

Appealing an award

Either owner who is unhappy with an award can appeal to the county court. Under section 10 of the Act, the appeal must be made within 14 days after the award is served. That is a short window, so do not leave it.

GOV.UK advises seeking legal advice if you are considering an appeal. Whether an award can be challenged, and on what grounds, is a legal question, and we cannot advise on it as surveyors. A solicitor who deals with party wall matters is the right person to ask.

What the Act cannot settle

The statutory process is powerful but it has edges.

  • Boundary disputes. GOV.UK’s booklet says the surveyors cannot decide where a boundary lies. If the real argument is about the boundary, the party wall procedure will not answer it.
  • Issues outside the Act. In a 2023 judgment, the Court of Appeal explained that section 10 applies to disputes arising under the 1996 Act and does not automatically absorb every common-law or equitable dispute that might relate to party wall work. Some problems may need separate legal remedies.

If your disagreement looks like either of these, speak to a solicitor. The surveyors can handle the building and procedural side; they cannot give legal advice on what falls outside the Act.

Keeping a dispute workable

The process can feel adversarial, but most disputes are settled calmly when both sides stay organised. GOV.UK’s guidance recommends starting with a friendly discussion and putting any agreement in writing. These habits help:

  • Talk before you serve. Show your neighbour the plans and explain what will happen and for how long.
  • Serve the right notice, correctly. A wrong or incomplete notice causes delay and ill feeling. Our guide on access rights sets out what each neighbour can expect.
  • Keep everything in writing. Dates matter because the 14-day and 10-day periods run from service.
  • Reply even if you are unsure. Your neighbour’s dissent does not stop the work from being possible. It only moves the decision to the surveyors.
  • Check which projects need notice. Many loft, extension and basement projects do. Our article on whether you need an agreement for a loft conversion is a good starting point.

Party wall support from Altura Surveyors

We are independent, RICS-regulated building surveyors covering Hampshire, Surrey and Berkshire, including Farnham, Winchester and Wokingham. Our party wall surveying service covers notices, awards and the surveyor role in a dispute, for both building owners and adjoining owners.

Altura Surveyors

We are a survey-only firm. We do not give legal advice, and where a question turns on the law or the boundary, we will say so and suggest you speak to a solicitor. Where we can help is with the building side: reading the proposed work, recording condition, and explaining the process in plain English. If you want to talk through your situation, you can book a call or request a quote.

FAQ

What happens if my neighbour ignores my party wall notice?

If they do not give written consent within 14 days, they are treated as dissenting and a dispute is deemed to have arisen. Surveyors then need to be appointed. If your neighbour does not appoint one within 10 days of a written request, you may appoint a surveyor on their behalf.

Can I stop my neighbour’s building work with the Party Wall Act?

The Act is not designed to stop work that is within the owner’s rights. The surveyors decide how and when work is done, and can require protective measures. Whether anything beyond that is possible is a legal question, so speak to a solicitor.

How is security for expenses set?

The surveyors agree or determine the amount and form, and record them in the award. According to RICS guidance, it may be held in an escrow account or in an RICS-regulated firm’s client account. An adjoining owner’s request must be made before the work starts.

How long do I have to appeal a party wall award?

You have 14 days after the award is served to appeal to the county court. Because the window is short, take legal advice as soon as you receive the award if you are thinking of challenging it.

Who pays for the surveyors in a dispute?

The award decides who pays which share, including the surveyors’ fees, according to GOV.UK. As a general starting point, the building owner is usually expected to bear the costs of the work they want to carry out, but the award governs what applies to your case. To discuss your own situation, contact us.

Sources

Altura Surveyors
Talk Through Your Party Wall Question
Contact Altura Surveyors to discuss party wall surveying and the findings or recommendations relevant to your property.

This article is general information only and is not a substitute for a survey or professional advice on a specific property. For advice on your property, contact Altura Surveyors.

blog author avatar

Altura Surveyors

Independent RICS-regulated building surveyors specialising in older, altered and higher-value homes across Hampshire, Berkshire and Surrey.

Back to Blog