
Tenant Dilapidation Defence: Your Options at Lease End
If your landlord has served a Schedule of Dilapidations, the figure at the bottom is a starting position, not a bill you must pay. A commercial tenant in England has several recognised ways to challenge a claim: testing whether each item is really your obligation under the lease, relying on the statutory cap in section 18 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, arguing that planned works make the repairs pointless (known as supersession), and removing upgrades the landlord is passing off as repairs. Each depends on evidence and on keeping to the timetable.
This guide explains how those defences work in plain English, what a tenant’s surveyor does, and where to get a lease-specific opinion. It covers commercial leases in England only. It is general information, not legal advice. For anything that turns on how your lease is worded, speak to a property litigation solicitor as well as a surveyor.
TL;DR
- Under the Dilapidations Protocol, the landlord’s schedule and your response each have a 56-day target. Courts expect both sides to follow it.
- Section 18(1) of the 1927 Act limits damages to the lower of the cost of repair or the loss in value of the landlord’s reversion.
- Supersession applies where the landlord plans demolition or structural alteration that makes your repairs valueless.
- Check every line for betterment, wish-list items and works the lease never required.
- Get an impartial surveyor involved early. Courts give weight to independent evidence, and surveys are visual and non-invasive, so the report records what can be seen.
Table of Contents
- What a dilapidations claim actually is
- The Dilapidations Protocol and your timetable
- Defence 1: Is the item really your obligation?
- Defence 2: The section 18(1) statutory cap
- Defence 3: Supersession
- Defence 4: Betterment and the landlord’s real scope
- Defence 5: Limitation and procedure
- The surveyor’s role: impartial evidence
- Talk early: settlement is common
- Before the lease ends: reduce the exposure
- How Altura Surveyors can help
- FAQ
- Book a survey
- Sources
What a dilapidations claim actually is
A lease usually obliges the tenant to keep the premises in repair, redecorate at set intervals and sometimes reinstate alterations at the end of the term. If the property is handed back in a worse state than the lease requires, the landlord can claim damages for the breach.
The landlord (or their surveyor) records the alleged breaches in a Schedule of Dilapidations. Each line normally gives the lease clause relied on, the work said to be needed and a cost. The RICS consumer guide to dilapidations in England and Wales sets out the common definitions, and is a useful companion to the lease itself.
Three points shape every defence:
- The lease decides the obligation. A schedule can only claim what the lease requires. Repair, decoration, reinstatement and legal compliance are separate heads, and wording differs between leases.
- The claim is for damages, not for the cost of works. Damages are capped by statute, which is why the headline number often overstates what is recoverable.
- The process matters. Missing steps in the protocol can count against you even where some of the claim is sound.
The Dilapidations Protocol and your timetable
The protocol applies to commercial property in England and Wales and covers terminal dilapidations claims, meaning claims made against tenants at the end of a tenancy. According to the protocol and its annex timetable, the landlord’s schedule and quantified demand are normally sent within 56 days after the tenancy ends, and the tenant’s response is normally due within 56 days of receiving them.

The protocol is not optional guidance that you can ignore. Courts look at whether each party complied when they decide on costs and sanctions, so a missed deadline can hurt you even where the underlying breach claim is weak.
The tenant’s response and the Scott Schedule
Your response should say, item by item, what you accept, what you dispute and why. In practice this is done in a Scott Schedule: a table with the landlord’s item and cost, your comment and your costing side by side. It forces a line-by-line justification and stops the claim going unchallenged.
A practical sequence for the first weeks after receiving a schedule:
- Note the date of receipt and diarise the 56-day response target.
- Collect the lease, any licences for alterations, the schedule of condition (if one was attached), and photographs and records from the start of the term.
- Ask a surveyor to inspect the property against the lease and the schedule.
- Ask your solicitor to confirm the lease interpretation, the limitation position and any break or service conditions.
- Prepare the response and Scott Schedule, and serve it within the target.
If you cannot meet the date, tell the landlord’s side in writing before it passes and say when you will respond. A short, documented explanation is better than silence.
Defence 1: Is the item really your obligation?
The first test is the simplest and often the most productive. Read the lease clause cited on each line and ask:
- Does the clause apply to this part of the building, or does the landlord insure or maintain it through a service charge?
- Is the standard in the lease “good repair”, “good and substantial repair” or something else? Repair does not normally mean renewal of something that is simply old.
- Was the alteration approved by a licence that says whether reinstatement is required?
- Was the item already in this condition when the lease began? A schedule of condition, if one exists, can matter a great deal.
- Is the work decorative, and has the decorating cycle in the lease actually fallen due?
Experts point out that many schedules include items that read like wish lists for upgrading the building. The GL Hearn briefing paper on section 18 valuations describes the tenant surveyor’s role as going beyond whether something is in disrepair, and testing the landlord’s real intention and whether the works are recoverable under the specific lease.
Defence 2: The section 18(1) statutory cap
Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 limits what a landlord can recover. As TWM Solicitors explain, damages are capped at the lower of the cost of the repairs and the diminution in the value of the landlord’s reversion caused by the breach.
The RICS Built Environment Journal’s analysis of Peachside v Lee notes that the first limb limits recovery to the loss in the reversion’s value, and discusses how the court approached cases where the landlord has already done the work.
Why valuation evidence sits beside survey evidence
A surveyor can assess the state of repair, the scope of works and a reasonable cost. The diminution in value is a valuation question, and a different type of expert deals with it. Altura Surveyors does not provide valuations, so if you need that evidence you would instruct a suitably qualified valuer alongside the building surveyor. What a building surveyor contributes is a clear, reasoned account of what is actually needed, which is the foundation the valuation work rests on.
Defence 3: Supersession
The second limb of section 18(1) protects a tenant where the landlord intends to demolish the building, or make structural alterations, so that the repairs would be valueless. This is what people usually mean by supersession. Where it applies, damages for those specific repairs are not recoverable, as TWM Solicitors summarise.
In practice, the questions are:
- What are the landlord’s plans, and is there evidence of them? Look for planning applications, appointed architects or contractors, board minutes, marketing material or correspondence.
- Were those plans formed at or near the end of the lease, or did they come later?
- Which items on the schedule would actually be removed, replaced or concealed by those works, and which would not?
The RICS journal piece on Peachside v Lee explains that the burden of proving these intentions often falls on the landlord, but you still need credible survey and valuation evidence to challenge the landlord’s account. Supersession is rarely all or nothing. A surveyor can map each schedule item against the proposed works so the argument covers only what genuinely falls away.
Defence 4: Betterment and the landlord’s real scope
Betterment means the landlord uses the claim to fund a better building than the one you leased. If an old, inefficient unit is replaced with a new, higher-specification one, you are only liable for the cost of repairing the original, not for the full replacement. HCR Law’s tenant guide identifies this as a frequent source of overpayment.
Typical places to look:
- Heating, ventilation and cooling plant replaced rather than repaired.
- Whole roof coverings renewed where localised repair would meet the covenant.
- New suspended ceilings, floor finishes or lighting to a higher standard than existed.
- Redecoration of areas that the landlord is going to strip out anyway.
Alongside betterment, check whether the landlord is mitigating loss. TWM Solicitors note that tenants can look at whether the landlord is failing to re-let, or chooses extensive refurbishment the lease did not require. Consequential losses such as loss of rent and professional fees are claimed on top of the works, so these deserve separate scrutiny too.
Defence 5: Limitation and procedure
Time limits can end a claim. According to TWM Solicitors, a claim that falls outside the statutory limitation period, typically 6 years for a simple contract or 12 years for a deed, counted from lease expiry, can be unenforceable. Most commercial leases are executed as deeds, so check how yours was made and ask your solicitor to confirm the period that applies.
Procedure is also part of the defence. If the landlord has not followed the protocol, for example by serving a schedule without costings, or very late, record it in your response. It is the court that decides what sanction, if any, follows.
The surveyor’s role: impartial evidence
A tenant’s surveyor does more than argue the schedule down. The RICS dilapidations guidance says a surveyor can be instructed as an adviser, expert witness or dispute resolver, and that professional objectivity is required in every role.
That matters in practice. The RICS journal’s discussion of Peachside v Lee highlights that courts place significant weight on independent surveyors’ evidence when the issue is whether repairs are necessary, and that an expert seen as too invested in advancing a client’s case risks undermining their credibility and your defence. A measured, well-reasoned report is more persuasive than an aggressive one.
What a good tenant-side inspection should include:
- A walk-through of the premises against the lease clauses and each schedule item.
- Dated photographs and notes, so the condition is recorded.
- An honest view on which items are valid. Conceding fair points makes the disputed ones more credible.
- Alternative scopes and costs for items that are overpriced or over-specified.
Be clear about what a survey can and cannot do. It is a visual, non-invasive inspection. The surveyor records what can be seen from accessible areas and does not open up structure or test concealed services. Where something needs further investigation, such as a specialist roof, drainage or mechanical check, the report should say so and recommend it.
Talk early: settlement is common
Not every claim needs to reach court. HCR Law’s guidance suggests landlords may accept a reduced lump sum to avoid the cost of litigation, or to get early possession, particularly where they have redevelopment plans. Early, documented communication can resolve matters faster than waiting for a formal process to reach its peak.
When you open a conversation, do it with your evidence ready. An offer backed by a surveyor’s reasoned costing is taken more seriously than a general complaint. Keep discussions on a clearly labelled “without prejudice” footing only on your solicitor’s advice, because that status has legal consequences.
Before the lease ends: reduce the exposure
The cheapest defence is the one you build before handover. If you are still in occupation:
- Read the repair, decoration, alteration and yielding-up clauses now, not at the end.
- Ask a surveyor to carry out a pre-termination inspection so you know the likely schedule and can decide what to repair yourself.
- Compare doing the work with paying damages, with your solicitor’s input on how that choice interacts with the lease.
- Collect licences for alterations and any records of previous works.
- Find out whether the landlord has plans for the building. That affects both strategy and supersession.
The same logic applies if you are the landlord’s side. A landlord who reaches a fair, evidenced number early usually avoids a long dispute. A commercial building survey is a sensible way to establish the condition of a building at either end of a term, and our guide to what to expect from commercial building surveys explains the process.
How Altura Surveyors can help
Altura Surveyors is an independent, RICS-regulated building surveying practice covering Hampshire, Berkshire and Surrey. We do surveying only, with no estate agency ties, so our advice is not shaped by a sales interest. Our dilapidations service covers reports for landlords and tenants, and we can set out the condition of a property in plain English, with repair recommendations.
If your issue is connected to works rather than a lease end, two related services may be relevant: a reinstatement cost assessment for insurance purposes, and contract administration for building works. We do not offer valuations and do not give legal advice, so for the section 18 diminution question and your lease interpretation you would work with a valuer and a solicitor as well.
FAQ
How long do I have to respond to a Schedule of Dilapidations?
Under the Dilapidations Protocol, the tenant’s response is normally due within 56 days of receiving the landlord’s schedule and quantified demand. Treat that as a firm target, because courts consider compliance when deciding on sanctions. If you need longer, tell the other side in writing before the date.
What does supersession mean in a dilapidations claim?
It is the second limb of section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927. Where the landlord intends to demolish or structurally alter the property so that your repairs would be valueless, damages for those repairs are not recoverable. You need evidence of the landlord’s plans, and a solicitor should confirm how it applies to your lease.
Do I have to pay for new equipment the landlord wants to install?
Not necessarily. If the landlord replaces old equipment with a higher-specification version, you are generally liable only for the cost of repairing the original item, not for the upgrade. A surveyor can compare the landlord’s scope with what the lease actually required.
Can a claim be too old to bring?
Possibly. Limitation periods are typically 6 years for a simple contract or 12 years for a deed, running from lease expiry. Because the answer depends on how your lease was executed, ask your solicitor to confirm.
Should I use the same surveyor the landlord suggests?
It is safer to instruct your own impartial surveyor. Courts look for objective evidence, so choose someone who will give a balanced view, including conceding items that are fair.
Book a survey
If you have received a Schedule of Dilapidations, or want to know your position before your lease ends, speak to us early so the 56-day target works in your favour. Contact Altura Surveyors to book and tell us about the property, the lease end date and where the claim stands. Consultations and quote requests are free.
Sources
- Dilapidations Protocol, Ministry of Justice
- Protocol Annex A timetable, Ministry of Justice
- Common defences to terminal dilapidations claims, TWM Solicitors
- Landlord and tenant at odds over section 18 provisions, RICS Built Environment Journal
- Dilapidations briefing paper on section 18 valuations, GL Hearn
- Dilapidations claims: a tenant’s guide, HCR Law
- Dilapidations guidance, RICS
- Dilapidations in England and Wales, RICS consumer guide
Recommended
This article is general information only and is not a substitute for a survey or professional advice on a specific property. For advice on your property, contact Altura Surveyors.